Lydia Laurenson recently posted an article called "The Inside Story of Leverage Research" that gets into substantially more detail on what went on in that organization and I thought made quite an interesting read. However, note also relevant Twitter comments from Oliver Habryka:

Having been around the ecosystem, having interned there, and having arguably worked there during my work at CEA it’s… a mediocre article.

It IMO puts the emphasis on largely the wrong things and the wrong dynamics, occasionally is dramatically wrong, and has some huge enormous missing moods. I do think almost all of what it says is literally true and I would recommend reading it to learn things about Leverage if someone is doing their own study and looking for facts, though wouldn’t recommend it for someone who is looking for a reasonable high level summary.

It somehow completely fails to cover Leverage deploying spies into other organizations and trying to take over CEA. It fails to cover the enormous number of straightforward lies told by Leverage staff in that and other contexts.

There is something that feels really weird about the article. As if the central story it is trying to tell is that Leverage fell apart due to no fault of any of its members because they encountered ancient magic or something. Which is a fun story to tell but really doesn’t map what actually happened IMO.

Also multiple people clearly had what I would describe as a psychotic break at Leverage and the casual disparagement of Zoe’s article really doesn’t feel good to me.

14

0
0

Reactions

0
0
Comments3
Sorted by Click to highlight new comments since:
huw
15
3
0

It somehow completely fails to cover Leverage deploying spies into other organizations and trying to take over CEA

I’ve heard this claim from Habryka and others many times and nobody seems to be willing to go on the record to back it up. He does not really think to ask that perhaps Lydia also heard about these rumours and was unable to substantiate them with the rigour required of a published magazine article either.

At least to just satisfy my curiosity, can someone involved privately DM me and explain what this means and provide some evidence for it?

(I otherwise fully agree with Habryka’s assessment that this article feels waaaaay too credible about Leverage and seems to be mostly doing image rehabilitation, from someone who is simply too personally close to the story to be believable as a third-party observer)

I'll go on the record about this! I cofounded CEA USA with Kerry Vaughan while also being closely affiliated with (but not paid by) Leverage during my CEA time. I was never aware of Leverage deploying spies or a goal to "take over" CEA. Although I wasn't part of the leadership team, so maybe I just didn't know about that kind of stuff.

Kerry and I co-created the first EA Global and worked hard on a lot of other EA infrastructure (student groups, funding coordination, talent coordination amongst EA orgs, etc). Just speaking for myself, I was a capital-T True Believer in the EA movement, and in many ways still am despite my critique. We sometimes had strategic disagreements with CEA Oxford, but I would not call this a takeover plot.

But Oli is my friend (hi Oli), and I think he's picking up on a real "vibe."

The vibe is that many Leverage people, myself included, were into the aesthetic of spies, conspiracy, secret societies and all that stuff. Even though we didn't actually do much of all that, this aesthetic made me feel cool and important.

Here's another thing Oli might be referencing: While coordinating with CEA UK, I didn't hide that I was living in the Leverage building. But at the same time, I gathered that the Oxford group profoundly distrusted Leverage, so I did not talk to Oxford people about the extent of my closeness with Leverage. This was mostly out of fear that they would socially ostracize me and not be able to hear why I thought Leverage was an important org at the time. When I finally did talk about my relationship with Leverage circa 2016, I was told that this could have been grounds for firing. I didn't get fired, but I quit soon after.

(To give credit to the Oxford crowd, I think they were right to be skeptical about Leverage! Although I think they were coming at it from a place of "This is Bay Area weirdness that's bad for the EA movement's reputation" that I sensed they had toward figures like Eliezer too. I don't know, possibly that's a caricature.)

Beyond that, I'll say this: Even though I was more faithfully going about my job than I think "take over CEA" indicates, I did see myself as primarily following the Leverage plan at the time. To Tyler Alterman in his 20s, the Leverage plan just seemed like the most complete and interesting plan for making the world a better place. Making the EA movement big and influential was a part of that wider plan, which also included all sorts of other crazy stuff like recursive self-improvement and reverse engineering esoteric traditions.

Cheers Tyler, and thanks for reviving your account to speak on it! Some of this stuff feels esoteric now, but I also think it sheds light on the lineage of modern EA, especially the split on the issue between the US and UK crowds (roughly).

I think this connects the dots on the story a bit, so thank you!

Curated and popular this week
Relevant opportunities