Hide table of contents

For context, I’m a student trying to choose a career where they can have maximum impact. One path I’m considering is founding a cleantech startup.

However, I’m worried that even if I found a startup, I might not actually increase the total amount of socially impactful work being done in the world.

Here’s my reasoning: suppose, very crudely, that the total social benefit produced by the cleantech sector scales with the number of cleantech startups that get funded. Also suppose there are more "viable" startups (i.e. startups that could plausibly become profitable if adequately financed) seeking funding than there are funding opportunities. If so, funding my company may simply displace capital from another viable startup. I would change which company gets funded, but not how many get funded, and therefore have little to no counterfactual impact.

I’ve considered a few possible counterarguments:

i) My startup could be more socially valuable than the one it displaces. But in areas like cleantech, many founders are already working on important problems, so I’m not sure I should expect mine to be better on average.

ii) My startup could be uniquely suited to my skills. But uniqueness alone doesn’t imply greater value; the displaced startup may also make a different but similarly valuable contribution.

iii) Exceptional companies can attract additional capital, so capital may cease to be the bottleneck for a sufficiently compelling startup. But founding an exceptional company is extremely rare / difficult, and I’m not sure it makes sense to base a career decision on that outcome.

iv) My underlying assumption may simply be wrong: perhaps there are actually more funding opportunities than “viable” cleantech startups. However, everything I’ve found so far suggests the opposite: there seem to be far more viable projects seeking funding than there are opportunities to fund them.

TL;DR: if I found a company in a sector where many other founders are already doing useful work, why should I expect my entry to increase the total amount of socially valuable work that gets done, rather than mostly reshuffling scarce capital?

I’ve been thinking about this for three weeks and haven’t found a satisfying answer. If anybody has any counterarguments, would really appreciate it...

3

0
0

Reactions

0
0
New Answer
New Comment
Comments2
Sorted by Click to highlight new comments since:

A few comments:

  1. While it's hard to beat the market at something it is optimizing for, it's not nearly as hard to beat the market at something it isn't optimizing for. The cleantech industry will optimize for profits, even if there's some standard of social impact that must be met. If you optimize for social impact instead, it's plausible you could be much more impactful per unit resources. The question is whether your startup would be commercially viable enough to scale.
  2. Be wary of degrees of freedom. The above claim assumes that you have some range of potentially commercial successful cleantech ideas. Depending on how competitive the market is, you might be forced into the most potentially profitable one rather than the most impactful one. Losing degrees of freedom is the big cost you pay when going for-profit rather than non-profit (but you gain scalability and long-term stability, which may be worth it).
  3. Make a model of impact that takes these counterfactuals into account directly. Model the expected impact of bringing about new technology, accounting for the costs of development and implementation (including costs that customers pay) and what those costs would have gone towards instead. Make an estimate for how socially impactful the marginal cleantech project would be. In general, projects that get funded will be more likely to scale than the projects they displaced. However, it's uncertain whether they're likely to be more or less impactful per unit resources, given the fact that the sector is not optimized for impact. You could look at a sample of projects and estimate the distribution of impact per unit resources (and maybe see if that correlates with scale - I'd guess weakly)
  4. Keep your options wide. For what it's worth, I expect that an impact-optimized founder with a comparative advantage for their work has a decent chance of launching something that is more impactful than the project they displace. However, it's very easy to overrate your comparative advantage for a given path and even easier to miss out on other opportunities. You mentioned that this is one of multiple paths you're considering. Keep it that way, and apply the same level of depth and rigor to each path.

If you haven't already, consider meeting a load of people working in the space e.g. by attending a conference / getting a relevant job / volunteering / emailing a few hundred people asking to chat directly. It's unlikely you'll get an accurate answer to your question without this step.

Curated and popular this week
Relevant opportunities