Hide table of contents

The UK government is consulting on ending CO₂ gassing of pigs, and you can respond (closes 21 December).

The proposal is to phase out high-concentration CO₂ stunning, with Defra's preferred option a three-year transition. 

Alternatives on the table are argon and automated electrical stunning, but Defra's modelling assumes most slaughterhouses would pick argon, which would mean swapping one gas for another in the same chambers. Project Slingshot (an animal welfare activist group) points out that the government's own advisory committee says inert gases "do not render the animals near-instantaneously unconscious", which suggests electrical stunning may be the better option.

You can respond here, on transition length and which alternative should replace CO₂: https://consultations.defra.gov.uk/phasing-out-carbon-dioxide-stunning-of-pigs

Things you might want to include:

  • Costs. AHDB estimates CO₂ stunning costs about 42p per pig, versus £1.36–1.49 for argon and about £1.11 for electrical.
  • Scale. Roughly 10 million pigs a year are stunned with CO₂ in the UK, so each extra year of transition means about that many more pigs going through it. Pigs exposed to high concentrations show clear signs of distress and adverse reactions.
  • Moral weight. Rethink Priorities' median welfare range estimate for pigs is 0.515 relative to humans (5th–95th percentile: 0.005–1.03). That roughly means a pig's range of possible suffering and wellbeing may be about half a human's, with a lot of uncertainty.

The consultation seems to be open to anyone, including people outside the UK, so I'd recommend filling it in.


 

28

0
0

Reactions

0
0
Comments3
Sorted by Click to highlight new comments since:

Is it important that argon render animals near-instantaneously unconscious? It just needs to reliably render them unconscious before slaughter and the process not be distressing (or not worse than the electrical stunning process).

Plus, electrical stunning could cause pain when it's botched, too. And the steps before the stunning could have welfare implications.

I guess I'm not sure what I'd recommend between argon and electrical stunning without seeing more evidence about how each would happen in practice, and potentially under improved guidelines/tech. Both seem better than CO2, though.

I would prefer nitrous oxide or xenon gas over argon, since those will make the pigs feel actively good as they are killed. But imo argon would be better than electric stunning, since it is likely just a slow drift out, whereas stunners could be painful.

Obviously, ideally no pigs would be killed without dire need, but that's not the world we live in.

My understanding is that electrical stunning is much faster than argon gassing- and the main reason that gassing is preferred by farms is that it is slightly cheaper. I agree that electrical stunning is likely as bad/worse if botched - which is why I opted for ‘automatic electrical stunning’ which seems likely to have a lower failure rate.


I agree that CO2 gassing is the worst of all, and that if this consultation can help bring about the end of this practice in the UK a year faster it would be a significant win

Curated and popular this week
Relevant opportunities