Edit: Some people have pointed out that this post fails to make an argument for why AI shouldn't be 80,000 Hours' core focus, and I think that's a fair criticism. I don't want people who are concerned about AI to think I'm dismissing their concerns. At this time, I'm still quite uncertain about the topic so I don't feel committed to any view regarding AI. This post is more about processing my frustration about losing a meta-EA org.
This is a crosspost from my blog.
For as long as “effective altruism” has been a term, 80,000 Hours has been one its most important organizations - introducing new people to EA’s core ideas and helping them to find impactful careers.
Since March 2025, this has no longer been the case. This is because 80,000 Hours now primarily focuses on funneling people into careers in AI with the assumption that humanity is on the verge of AGI, which they believe could determine humanity’s future, possibly by bringing about either utopia or apocalypse.
I think this is a deep loss for EA, and I wanted to share some reasons why:
1. There’s no longer a good resource to introduce people to EA.
80,000 Hours’ career guide and its problem profiles used to be the very best resource for introducing people to the core ideas behind EA and motivating them to pursue impactful careers.
Now that it has an AGI worldview baked into its content, it no longer really fulfills that purpose since it’s about AI rather than EA.
This is quite sad to me given that, for a long time, 80,000 Hours was my favorite website, and I used to mention it to people quite often.
Now, I feel quite uncomfortable sharing it with people.
For those looking for alternative resources, Probably Good is an EA career advice site that’s similar to how 80,000 Hours used to be, although it has a lot less content.
The Intro to EA page is also quite good.
2. EA should be about diversity of thought
Since EA is about finding the most effective ways to do good, I think that diversity of thought is paramount to its success as a project. This is because you really can only expand and refine your worldview in a responsible way when you engage with people who disagree with you or offer different perspectives.
Given that 80,000 Hours puts the imminence of AGI as the background assumption to its content, it cuts off virtually all other worldviews about what “doing the most good” should look like.
In the worst case scenario, if 80,000 Hours turns EA into just another AI worldview, that strips EA of its fundamental value as “the science of doing good.”
3. Less people are discovering EA now.
According to the EA Survey 2024, 80,000 Hours was the second most common way that people learned about EA.
Since 80,000 Hours now focuses on funneling people into AI safety rather than EA, the EA movement will need to find new ways to gain attention.
4. 80,000 Hours’ content is increasingly bizarre, which is bad for EA.
80,000 Hours’ problem profiles page has 14 cause areas highlighted.
Of these, roughly eight are very esoteric and strange. (“Extreme power concentration [from AI],” “Engineered pandemics,” “Moral status of digital minds,” “Gradual disempowerment,” “S-risks,” “AI-enhanced decision making,” “Space governance,” and “Wild animal suffering”).
I would feel pretty uncomfortable endorsing these ideas at a party, and I imagine you would be too.
Overall, I think that EA’s willingness to approach topics that are unusual is one of its strengths because it allows it to identify important problems that others overlook.
At the same time, it seems like 80,000 Hours has gone too far in this direction. Since 80,000 Hours still represents EA to some degree, this is bad for the movement.
It’s important to be willing to entertain ideas even if they sound a bit unusual, but putting a large spotlight on the movement’s most bizarre ideas is a bad idea.
For one, it implicitly endorses the idea that the more strange an idea is, the more likely it is to be impactful. This turns EA as a project into a search for increasingly bizarre ideas by setting bizarreness as a goal rather than a happenstance.
For two, it pushes away people with normal worldviews and only selects people with a high openness to very strange ideas. This reduces EA’s impact by reducing the size of the movement. It also eliminates the movement’s ability to orient towards the truth by reducing internal pushback to its ideas.
Hey, writing in my personal capacity (but gave others from 80k the chance to suggest edits).
I want to write a comment that’s a bit more raw than usual. I think I might die, because we don’t have control of AI. And I think you might die, and also my parents and also everyone else. Potentially very very soon.
It is a terrible position for the world to be in.
I can’t imagine being excited about an EA that looks at those facts and doesn’t jump into action. Obviously you might disagree with those facts! Great, let’s argue about that. This post doesn’t try to argue for or against x-risk, or try to take the view of why 80k might do this.
I’ve heard this argument, that EA is about finding and thinking about the most effective ways to do good. That seems right and good to me. But surely it is also about doing them.
I’m not saying I’m not excited for people to just be engaged in asking the question, I am! For instance I’m on the board of NEST.
But from my perspective, this post, which I want to recognize cares about protecting something I hold very dear, is missing a very serious mood.
I don’t think 80,000 Hours cuts off other worldviews about doing the most good, I think it has an opinion about what doing the most good, right now, on October 27, 2026, looks like. 80,000 Hours has always had opinions about that, it’s had a ranked list for over a decade.
As for esoteric concerns, I think you and I just disagree about how to relate to them, but for what it’s worth, I think e.g. engineered pandemics and extreme power concentration (imagine Trump or some other head of state, especially a dictator, with a superintelligent army) are potentially extremely extremely near to hand.
This is an passionate reply which makes a lot of sense but to some extent attacks a strawman.
The post wasn't trying to argue over which cause was most important (although he did wade into that). It primarily argues that
1. We lost our best resource to introduce neutral people to EA. Like the OP there are very few people I can now refer to 80,000 hours
2. Diversity of thought about cause-priority is important in EA, and previously seemed to be part of the ethos of 80,000 hours.
Having a ranked list with AI safety clearly at the top is very different from deliberately encouraging everyone to work on AI risk
Again I think you guys are doing amazing work and love the energy of this reply, I just think it argues a different point from the OP. Of course 80,000 hours has every right to do what it wants and may well have made the right decision, despite the cost.
Yeah I agree there's a central claim which is "80k switching to AI is a loss for cause neutral EA" which I basically agree with (and then think is right for the world, ala Matt Reardon's comment) but I do think it would be harder to have this orientation if you thought AI risk was really imminent / severe / etc, and so that's where the real crux is.
Yeah, I agree with Chana.
I think that, if there is some cause area that is distinctly more important than all other cause areas, it would make a lot of sense for 80k to simply shift to focusing on that cause area.
Like, if 95% of virologists thought an engineered pandemic could wipe out humanity in the next ten years and 80k shifted to just focusing on preventing engineered pandemics, I wouldn't be saying that that is a "loss" for EA.
That said, in general, it seems very hard to compare cause areas because of the epistemic limitations we face in predicting the consequences of our actions, in understanding our world, and in determining how to act under different kinds of uncertainty. As such, I generally would prefer 80,000 Hours to be more cause neutral.
Hi Chana,
Thanks for taking time out of your day to respond to my post, and I appreciate your honesty.
To be clear, I have spent a significant amount of time looking into AI. I have read most of 80k's AI content and seen many of your podcasts and all of the AI In Context videos (as well as a lot of other AI content), and I still find myself feeling that I would need to research the topic a lot more to feel convinced about risks from AI takeover. Given this, it's not that I think that AI takeover won't happen as much as I don't have a strong view either way, and I feel I need to research the topic more.
Given this, I was writing the post with the assumption that AI takeover should not be EA's dominant focus, and I definitely understand your criticism that I haven't sufficiently made the argument for that assumption.
I want to make clear that I'm very sympathetic to concerns about AI takeover, and I don't want people at 80k to feel that I'm dismissing their work.
As someone with a more vanilla EA worldview, my intent in writing this was to process my frustration for losing a meta EA org, not to invalidate the work of others.
I have added an edit to the top of the post to make these caveats and my intent clear. I apologize for not initially including them. Thanks for responding so thoughtfully.
That said, I do think many of the problem profiles really are very esoteric in that, if we were to re-play the 21st century, it's unlikely most of these concerns would be discovered/created.
For instance, Forethought's work, which inspired the "AI-enhanced decision making profile" and, to some extent, the "Space governance" and "Extreme power concentration" profiles is very bizarre and only makes sense in context to the mythology created by FHI. For instance, one of their recent articles is "A nightwatchman on every probe: Superintelligent surveillance to prevent galactic anarchy." To me, this is a very fringe idea that has many assumptions about the future and the extent to which we can influence it baked into it. I think that much of Forethought's work is a concerning departure from the very evidence-based roots of the movement and the significantly researched concerns about AI, and I think their work is indicative of an extreme echo chamber.
Given this, I do think it's problematic for 80,000 Hours to highlight their work given how fringe and speculative it is.
It feels like EA has, at its edges, a tendency to push towards increasingly unusual topics, but it's important to not let that be motivated by social factors rather than evidential ones. (For instance, there is actually strong evidence that shrimp are sentient. The same cannot be said for whether we need to start coming up with considerations for what principles should be baked into superintelligent interstellar probes.)
Also, despite spending a couple of hours looking for it, I have been unable to find evidence that engineered pandemics are a mainstream concern among biosecurity experts, which makes me pretty skeptical that we should be concerned about them.
I agree that GHD and neartermist interventions are far easier to collect evidence about (e.g. you can just run RCTs!) but I think that doesn't mean we should avoid thinking about speculative and future-oriented things.
Re being an echo-chamber, it is true that there is a very small (but growing!) set of people thinking about the intelligence explosion and what it might entail. I'm glad to see more and more people taking AI seriously and thinking about what RSI would mean and what risks it poses. The alternative to us publishing work like this is just leaving it in google docs that 'echo chamber' people comment on. So I think where possible and not infohazardous to do so, sharing work like this publicly is useful. I'd be happy to see thoughtful critiques of the piece! Though I expect we have fundamental enough disagreements (e.g. about the legacy of FHI - to me it seems like it was a prescient and very generative place) that it would be hard to double-crux.
(I co-wrote the Nightwatchmen article.)
Hi Oscar,
I do think that taking the future into account when making decisions is important and that this process can inevitably come down to a lot of subjective speculations. For instance, when comparing the importance of alternative proteins to other approaches for helping animals, the best we can really do is making subjective predictions.
That said, I think that Forethought goes too far with its speculation by attempting to approach a vast space of future possibilities with minimal revision and external dispute about its ideas. To me, it seems like, if any of the ideas discussed by the authors were approached by different people, very different conclusions and visions of the future would be come to because the organization's approach to outlining the future is methodologically flawed. For this reason, it doesn't seem like virtually any of the research would pass peer review.
If I have time, it would be very interesting to critique the piece and hear your thoughts!
Also, thanks for the cordial response given my criticism of your piece. I wasn't expecting that you'd see my comment.
Thanks :)
That makes sense, yes I think there is something of a rigour-importance tradeoff where some of the most important questions are hard to address as rigorously. Probably even in global development, where things you can do RCTs on are great, but improving economic growth is far harder to rigorously measure and analyse.
One of my worries with articles like the one we wrote is that most of this can just be left to figure out after we have solved alignment and are in some sort of long (or short) reflection period. I still find it useful to think about these big picture strategy futurism things sometimes even if any answers we come to will need to be somewhat tentative and to-be-revised.
Appreciate your engagement here and the caveat you left at the top of the post <3
Even if AI safety is overwhelmingly the most important cause, narrowing the 80k podcast hurts AI safety.
80k’s most important function, even on those terms, has been bringing new people into EA. People came for career advice or an episode on global health or animal welfare, picked up the habit of asking what matters most, and many of them ended up working on AI safety or funding it. A few people in this thread describe updating toward AI after they were already in EA. That pipeline runs on broad content. An AI-focused show reaches people already drawn to AI. It misses the people who start from wanting to do the most good and wouldn’t pick up an AI podcast on their own, and a lot of AI safety’s people and money came from that group.
The breadth also made the AI case more persuasive. “80k looked at every cause and AI came out on top” carries more weight than the same verdict from a show that only covers AI.
None of this needed a tradeoff. 80k already showed how with video: AI in Context is its own channel, and its first video has over 10 million views. The AI episodes could have launched as a separate podcast the same way, with the main feed kept broad. That serves both audiences. A second feed costs some staff time and money. Narrowing one of EA’s main entry points costs AI safety much more.
This isn't right!!
I've found these compelling, and continue to do so.
I also think that EAs, who try to be morally and epistemically decent, can contribute to making AGI go well particularly well, as my then-colleague argued for here.
These are an important part of why we stayed cause neutral for so long.
But I think it was a mistake that we did so. (And it was my mistake, as I was interim CEO in 2023, and I now think we should have switched then.)
As the ratio of [people wanting to do something about AI] : [people wanting to help others in the abstract] grows, my intuition is that taking tradeoffs in capturing the latter in favour of the former will let us have more impact.
Ex post our metrics have been broadly consistent with that view, and I still hold that it's the right judgement call overall ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Maybe this feels important to me for a similar reason to what Chana #vibed. I love EA as a question. And if there was no tradeoff, I claim that 80k leadership would have definitely left 80k doing what it was doing.
But my goodness me, there was a sharp tradeoff, unfortunately :(
Fair enough, I was wrong that there was no tradeoff.
Your point about podcasts growing slowly makes me think I had it backwards. The existing audience should go to the most urgent thing, so if anything, the way to minimize the tradeoff would have been to make the main feed about AI safety and announce a separate general feed. That would probably cost more than it sounds. It pulls from the same capacity you said is so hard to build, and it would start small and take a long time to grow. It could also muddy a focus that seems to be working for you.
But it would have kept some of what made you stay cause neutral as long as you did. You said you still find the pipeline and credibility arguments compelling, along with your former colleague’s case for building EA, and a general feed would have kept those going.
Overall though, I think your call makes a lot of sense. If the building is on fire, it makes more sense to figure out how to get people out than to work out whether other projects are more valuable.
Thank you Brad, I appreciate the response!
As some extra colour here, just for interest: For a little while in 2023 I quite liked the idea of the AI safety focused part of 80k spinning off. The existing feed would say that making AGI go well seemed to be the most important cause, but it would keep the existing flow about the 'question' of how to use careers to do the most good. I expect that most staff would have left to the new org, which itself could have been called 10,000 Hours or something, and tried to produce some sort of media splash. This fit well with some instincts I have (which not everyone agrees with) about 'what organisational missions are for', and it felt very neat to me. But yeah, ultimately I think what we did was the right move. (Though if I thought that we could have built up other channels as rapidly as we did AiC then I wouldn't have held this view.)
Still though 80,000 hours could have produced these videos directly from the 80,000 hours account without going AI only. It seems to me a strawman that you would have had to make these videos form a separate platform.
This is a different - and more obvious - trade-off, though. "Going AI only" means more AI content at the cost of producing not-AI-related content.
This thread is going down the route of "given your updated cause prio, should you have created a new brand instead"
Yeah, I definitely wonder if you're right about this. As someone who's unsure about AI, I'd much prefer people to come to AI by being curious about EA first rather than having it be the main idea they're exposed to because then that's a strong indicator that AI is something worth being seriously worried about.
It also seems like 80k's AI-focused guide could have been more of a spun-out project or just one part of their site rather than being the whole thing and that would have had a similar/higher level of impact because of the selection effect you mentioned.
80K's cause area list has had esoteric stuff for years now, and their career guide still seems to be mostly generally appealing. There are some AI-focused write-ups (part 9 seems to have undergone revision), but most of the core write-ups look exactly like they used to two years ago.
I think it is still the highest quality career guide out there and still worth recommending it to newcomers.
--
I don't know if their pivot was detrimental for the world. It is possible that the future will unfold exactly how the Berkeley people think it will, in which case, maybe it was positive. Even if it doesn't, it could still be argued that the pivot was positive.
But the loss of 80K as a cause general meta EA org has most likely been bad for the community, and especially for those who are not into AIS. They used to effectively function as a movement building / comms org. Their podcast was the best way to learn what prominent EAs were working on and the set of ideas the movement was into, but their pivot left a vacuum that I doubt will be filled any time soon.[1]
On a personal level, I miss when 80K's podcast episodes were more varied. It was my top podcast from ~2021 to 2024, but I no longer engage with their content (partly because my brain is oversaturated with AI content, but also because there are other podcasts like Dwarkesh that do a pretty good job of talking about TAI without an overwhelming focus on AIS).
I think other people have done a good job pointing out that the unargued-for underlying crux of this post seems to be "I disagree about AI risk", but I just want to highlight how strange this one section struck me as:
Like... of course not? I would be happy arguing for any of these among normie friends (e.g. the parents of my kids' friends). Many of these claims are not "very esoteric" at all - e.g. 40% of Americans believe(d at time of polling) that we have already had an engineered pandemic! Obviously I can't speak for the type of parties you attend or how open-minded your friends are, and of course the most important issue is truth, not social desirability, but I think you seem quite poorly calibrated about how uncomfortable most of these positions are.
Agreed! Questions like whether it's ok to be mean to Claude, how to square caring about animals with our normal "leave nature alone" attitude, or whether the people are gradually being hollowed out by having GPT do all their thinking, are all things I might talk about with contra dance friends or park parents. I wouldn't open a conversation with them, since they could get a bit intense, but they're all places that wouldn't feel out of bounds and I'd be happy to bring them up or steer a conversation that way. And when people ask what I work on and I say building a detection system for engineered pandemics, the normal response is something like "I'm glad someone is working on that!"
I think it's worth noting that 5/8 of the problem profiles you call bizarre are bundled under a single "Emerging Priorities" problem. I also think these five are substantially more bizarre-sounding than the other three and that their being bundled in this way reflects a reasonable self-awareness on 80k's part.
Separately, this does not follow from 80k listing the priorities that they do:
Neglectedness is an independent desiderata. Because of this, EA priorities will often appear more bizarre than more familiar priorities (because neglectedness correlates with bizarreness), but that does not mean EAs (or 80k in this case) are trying to maximize bizarreness unconstrained by strong arguments for overall importance and tractability.
I used to think something along those lines, but given what happened since the release of Opus 4.5 in November 2025, I now personally believe that EA as a whole is not focusing on AI enough.
I also believe that 80,000 Hours doesn't get enough credit for having pushed for focusing on what's most important since well before it was so clear and popular, and people like me who were complaining about them just telling everyone to work in AI should apologize and update sooner rather than later.
Some thoughts on your points:
I agree that 80k was possibly the best, but the two you link are also good, there's also https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/handbook which imho is still decent despite (or maybe thanks to?) being unmaintained
I personally strongly disagree with this, EA should be about helping others effectively. “the science of doing good” should reject "alternative science".
I'm not claiming that there is consensus among reasonable people that trying to influence the potential upcoming transition in a positive way is the best way to help others, but you shouldn't embrace diversity of views for its own sake.
This seems less important than people moving into careers that are better for the world, or donating more money, or influencing policy, or many other things. So I think it makes sense that more and more organizations are focusing on results rather than on EA's growth. I also don't think it's true (the US Department of War tweeted about effective altruism, The Economist had an article on EA on its front page, there's a major Netflix series coming out in November, ...)
Also, lots of people are still getting into non-AI EA from 80k. In the past 6 months 24 people signed the 10% pledge with 80k as a primary source. Given the massive interest in AI and 80k's AI focus, I expect that tons of people are discovering 80k and through it EA.
I think CEA is focusing on having very simplified, normie-friendly pages, without mentioning anything weird like the fact that most life in the next century might be of non-biological origin and deeply uncertain about its own moral status. I think it makes sense for CEA's content to focus on the EA brand and for 80k on how to do the most good with your career (see below on focus)
I think there's a very important difference between not endorsing those ideas because you disagree with them and not endorsing them because they're too weird or far from the social norm. I also feel uncomfortable mentioning significant donations and animal welfare, but I think that positively correlates with those things being very important to talk more about, because I deeply believe the related ideas to be true, and the discomfort is due to mistaken norms and beliefs.
Those are very far from the movement's most bizarre ideas, they are all reasonable things to focus on, and 80k's reasoning for focusing on those is well laid out, they're obviously not writing them just because they are bizarre.
To be clear I think it would be weird and bad if CEA redefined "effective altruism" to be about positively influencing this potential transition, instead of being about trying to help others from a broad range of perspectives, but I think what 80k is doing is very good for EA and for the world, and many more of us should be doing similar things.
I personally don't think you need to commit to the view that AI takeover is likely to encourage more focus on influencing upcoming transformative technology, you just need to believe that it's reasonably likely to be transformative and that there are reasonable enough theories of change to try to influence that transition in a more positive way.
Separately from considerations about the relative importance of AI, I also think from the outside it can be very hard to appreciate the value of focusing (see e.g. GWWC retiring 10 initiatives, which internally we called "Project Focus", led to clear significant growth in our key metrics and was extremely successful).
By focusing more on their respective priorities, CEA and 80,000 Hours can be much more effective than they would by trying to do everything.
On a personal level, I share some of your sadness at 80k's change in focus. I used to listen to every single episode of the 80k podcast and recommend it to anyone who asked, and I just don't get the same level of enjoyment out of it without the previous level of content diversity. But I can't fault 80k for their overall change in focus. AI risks that looked speculative as of a few years ago are seeming increasingly close to real, whether that's loss of control (see the hugging face swarm) or AI-enabled cyber risk (see the recent discovery of vulnerabilities in PHP). With that in mind, I think that several of the problem profiles you highlighted as "esoteric and strange" really aren't that out-there, and I expect that many visitors to the 80k website who have seen some of the latest AI news would agree.
Moreover, EA is about trying to do good with evidence and reason, and that means it needs to involve a balance between identifying the most effective ways to do good and actually going and doing those things. So while I agree that it's a loss to no longer have as good a cause-neutral EA introduction and to lose a common intro EA funnel, I think that can reasonably be counterbalanced by having a better resource for getting people to work on addressing pressing problems related to AI. Not every EA org needs to be cause-neutral, and it's reasonable for organizations to shift their role in response to changes in circumstances.
Thanks for the thoughtful response!
I agree that *EA* has lost something here, but 80k has a strong argument that *the world* has gained enough from the change to offset that loss. They think the impact of the users attracted by- and directed-to AI safety and these more niche areas will outweigh the impact of users turned off by their unusual priorities. It's a conscious decision on their part. I've talked to them about it.
The broader point is that EA is not self recommending. Sometimes the most EA thing to do is not to dwell on cause prioritization, but to act under greater-than-ideal amounts of uncertainty or public appeal.
Thanks James I agree with you broadly. I don't think any org at the top of the EA funnel should fix themselves to a cause area.
I do though want to give 80,000 hours credit for their work after they made this decision. I wrote a pretty critical take (similar-ish to yours) just after they made this decision to Go full AI, and I think since then they have done a great job on their chosen path. They have proved with their great videos, podcasts and articles that they can be the chief AI-Safety community building org. Getting multiple-million views on videos is pretty impressive.
The rapid increase in AI capabilities and seeming probabilities of AI-caused disaster has to some extent vindicated their choice to go Full-AI a couple of years ago. I was wrong about AI risk, and the world has changed to favour their bet. So respect to them on that front.
I think @Probably Good is the obvious org to come through and replace 80,000 hours. They've had a lot more funding, decent materials and by all accounts a good career advice service. But I don't think they have got anywhere near replacing 80,000 hours. I don't think their comms or website are quite compelling enough and their writing on the forum has been a bit lackluster too. I hope they improve!
Yeah, I'm definitely sympathetic to people's concerns about AI as you are, although I guess the concern is so speculative and extraordinary that I find it difficult to believe it should be almost every visitor to 80k's primary career choice.
I think this is a very bad take. AI is overwhelmingly more important than the other stuff. It's good for 80k to focus on it heavily or exclusively.
If your point is "I disagree that AI is important", then write that post and make that argument. Don't write a drive by critique of people doing excellent work and doing it even more excellently by focusing on the things that matter most. That's the whole point, after all.
I'm very interested in preserving EA as a movement, but I don't have very strong opinions about AI. That's why I wrote the post in this way.
The idea that AI will disempower humanity is such an extraordinary claim that I think I would need to spend a very long time researching it before coming to any strong conclusions about it. I've read a lot of "AI safety" texts, but some of the most popular ones seem more like sci-fi world-building than arguments so I feel I have good reason to be skeptical of the topic.
Given this, I'd, currently, rather spend my time looking into other topics. After all, researching AI comes with a large opportunity cost.
What's the point of preserving EA as a movement if EA can't direct people to work on the most important problem that it has identified?
The fact that you don't personally have a completely independent position on AI is part of why it's so important for serious organizations who have actually done this kind of thinking to very clearly emphasize how central the issues with AI are. Yes, they are extraordinary claims, AND there's a giant community of people who have substantially converged on the importance of AI.
Of course, doing anything comes with a large opportunity cost. The point isn't to notice that there's a large opportunity cost. The point is to try to find the thing that has the lowest opportunity cost.
I hear you that things can end up sounding sci-fi. Where do you first start objecting to the story in AI 2027, for example?
Another issue is that there is no longer any org that produces career prioritization research.
I suspect people have the mistaken notion that this area of research is just a reflection of philanthropic prioritization; the places it is advisable to recommend donations are also the best to recommend for careers. But this is a major simplification, even though there's a lot of overlap. Altrusitically optimal career trajectories are waaaaay broader and more obscure due to personal fit and labour market demand considerations.
Probably good doesn't do this. 80k used to do this well, but now they are just another AI safety advocacy group (no slight intended, those are needed too).
That's a really great point, Dylan!
I wonder if CEA is thinking about how to fill the gap. I also used to recommend 80,000 Hours and their podcast all the time. I also no longer do that. I'm sure we're not alone.
TBC, I'm super-concerned about AI safety, but it's not the only thing I'm concerned about.
I also wonder if by focusing on AI safety so exclusively, they're not losing quite a few people who will no longer find them at all due to their decision to focus so much on one thing...
Yeah, I definitely wonder that too.
I discovered EA at 22 so I generally feel like EA needs to do a better job at making the general population aware of its ideas.