TL;DR: EA has traditionally deprioritized climate change as a cause area. But a new report from Rethink Priorities, an EA research institute, suggests that specific Earth systems risks driven by climate change could have mortality impacts comparable to major global health burdens, on top of the known damages of climate change.
The report finds that research and governance work on ‘Earth Systems Stabilization’ to establish whether safe options to address these risks exist clears EA cost-effectiveness bars and justifies significant funding.
Disclosure: I run the Climate Change program at The Navigation Fund, a philanthropic foundation that also works on Farm Animal Welfare and Transforming Criminal Justice. Building on these research findings, we will be jointly launching an Earth Systems Stabilization Fund with Outlier Projects, who commissioned the research. The report interviews me and leaders of organizations we already support and recommends funding work in areas where they operate.
When we launched The Navigation Fund’s Climate Change program last year, we looked for an area within climate change where our dollars could be especially effective. One area we’ve chosen to focus on is “Earth Systems Stabilization” - a new umbrella term to describe the work of understanding, predicting, and trying to prevent the deterioration of critical Earth systems impacted by climate change. Here we mean things like:
- Increasing ecosystem emissions: Rising temperatures are increasing emissions from ecosystems. Tropical wetland outgassing, thawing permafrost, and forest fires account for a growing share of total emissions. These feedback loops could amplify global warming by 30%.
- Weakening ocean currents: A massive system of ocean currents called the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) could significantly weaken this century. This would severely disrupt Asian and West African monsoons and shift the global tropical rainbelt southward, causing major droughts in some regions and catastrophic flooding in others.
- Declining planetary reflectivity: Declining cloud cover and sea ice are making the Earth less reflective, causing it to absorb much more solar energy.
- Rising sea levels: Sea levels are now predicted to rise 2–7 feet by 2100 which would displace hundreds of millions of people. More than 90% of risk and uncertainty is due to instability in the Thwaites Glacier in West Antarctica.
- Response options: Approaches to managing these risks include climate interventions like stratospheric aerosol injection, marine cloud brightening, and ice-sheet stabilization (all covered in the report), as well as other approaches like wetland management, sea-ice thickening, methane mitigation, and wildfire prevention (not in the report).
These risks do not depend on pessimistic assumptions about future emissions trajectories; some risks, like rising sea levels due to Thwaites Glacier, have tipping-point dynamics where today’s warming may already be enough to lock in substantial future loss. This makes it a distinct but complementary field to decarbonization, because it targets risks that emissions cuts alone will not address. A forum post from May 2026, "Climate Stabilization: A draft ITN update", makes the conceptual case for EA funding in much greater detail.
We think that Earth Systems Stabilization deserves more attention and resources, but traditional climate philanthropy has neglected to invest in understanding and addressing these specific risks despite their massive impact (by our estimate, funding is in the low tens of millions annually). To assess whether this work would make sense as an EA funding priority, Outlier Projects commissioned Rethink Priorities to investigate this work and evaluate it against EA benchmarks for impact.
The report comes to a clear conclusion: Earth systems instabilities could cause millions of deaths, and an EA fund in the hundreds of millions of dollars to address these risks is well-justified. We agree with these conclusions. However, we (and Rethink Priorities) would like to continue to stress-test the assumptions behind this argument, and invite questions, comments, and suggestions for further research.
Below, I’ve included Rethink Priorities’ full executive summary from their Substack post launching the report. Rethink Priorities also did a presentation on their report at EAG NYC 2026 which directly compared mortality from Earth systems instabilities to global health issues like malaria, which I’ll add to this post when available.
Click here to see the full report.
Earth Systems Risks and the Case for Funding Stabilization Research
Why new evidence suggests the effective altruism community should reconsider its approach to climate research
In research commissioned by Outlier Projects, Rethink Priorities’ Global Health and Development team reviewed recent climate science and interviewed roughly 20 experts. We asked whether there is a case for the EA community to fund research on Earth systems stabilization. We concluded that there is.
The effective altruism community has historically deprioritized climate change as a cause area for two main reasons. The first is a judgment that climate change is unlikely to pose a direct existential risk to humanity (Ord, 2020; Hilton, 2022). The second is that it is not neglected: global climate funding from public and private sources reached approximately $1.3 trillion annually between 2021 and 2022 (Buchner et al., 2023; UNFCCC, 2024).
However, Earth system destabilization could be considered distinct from the broader climate change area, because it involves the triggering of mechanisms that can effectively decouple from the rise (and ideally later fall) of global average temperatures.
Evidence published since IPCC AR6 suggests that several Earth systems (ice sheets, the AMOC, planetary albedo, frozen carbon stores) are destabilizing faster than models predicted. Many of these have potentially irreversible, self-reinforcing dynamics that would be unresponsive to future reductions in global average temperatures, once triggered.
The human harms of destabilization are large even on deliberately conservative estimates. Counting only direct mortality (no morbidity, economic damage, or interactions between risks), our BOTECs find: ~15 million excess deaths by 2100 per additional degree of warming; $17.8 trillion in philanthropic value at stake from 1.5m of sea level rise (230 million people live below 1m above the high-tide line today); and $10.5 trillion in probability-weighted damages from a 15% chance of AMOC collapse.
This justifies a fund in the low- to mid-hundreds of millions. At Coefficient Giving’s (CG) old 2000x bar, each of the four risks individually supports an EA community willingness to pay of $263–445 million (single funder: $131–223 million) for research and governance work. These numbers would need to be off by 3–4 orders of magnitude for the case to entirely collapse. Moreover, CG’s bar has fallen to 1000x since publication, effectively doubling our WTP estimates for averting deaths in this cause area.
We explore the mechanisms and funding landscape of three candidate climate stabilization approaches: stratospheric aerosol injection, marine cloud brightening/thinning, and ice-sheet stabilization. All are contested, and none are deployment-ready. We recommend funding the research and governance work needed to establish whether safe, workable options exist.
For those who would like to explore the research in more depth, the full report is available on the Rethink Priorities website, and a summary of the key findings is available on RP Research Digest, our Substack publication.
I think these interventions may make sense, but it makes me sad that this could be another line of thinking which could make all of EA more unpopular again, especially when there's a bit of a public comeback afoot?
This doesn't mean we shouldn't do this research, I just think its an important point to consider. Not just for PR reasons, but also to make sure scientists working on this dont' get maligned and that this line of science doesn't get shut down for ideological reasons.
I do wonder whether it might be important to do this kind of research explicitly alongside governments and mainstream climate scientists, as much as possible. If it turns out the best option is to manually mess with our atmosphere and ice-sheets, I suspect the bottleneck might be public opinion and politics more than the science.
On the other hand maybe its best to start with a little quiet-ish research in the background... But "low hundreds of millions" wouldn't be quiet lol.
Hi Nick,
Thanks for the comment. That's a real risk and worth managing. This is one of the questions we're thinking through on the new Fund. Certainly agree that politics and governance is a critical piece to get right! Much of the work of the field right now is focused on engaging governments and the mainstream climate community to embed research into these risks as a standard part of climate action.
What we've found working on this so far is that there's a lot more people who see the need for for this research to take place than expected. So, initial engagement and dollars help widen the circle of people with credibility working on it, in turn making it easier for new people to come in, etc. Unfortunately, actors with much worse PR (like Stardust, an Israeli-American VC-funded company researching sunlight reflection) are running ahead and risking backlash, and we can't assume the default is years of quietness ahead.
Fantastic response love it. Makes me more comfortable all this already.
Hi Liam. Thanks for sharing. Here is a quick check of one of the assumptions. The share of people with food insecurity in Northern and Western Europe in 2023 was 7.30 % and 6.00 %, around 6.65 % (= (0.0730 + 0.0600)/2). @Rethink Priorities (RP) assumes AMOC's collapse would increase that share by 6 pp (with a range of 1pp to 10 pp), 90.2 % (= 0.06/0.0665), thus bringing it to 12.6 % (= 0.0665 + 0.06). The share of people with food insecurity almost doubling seems high to me, but I do not know. The sheet only says the increase of 6 pp is "based on expected crop yield losses of ~30% in Europe".
Hi Vasco,
Thanks for the check. I'll let RP provide a more technical answer here.
Thanks @Vasco Grilo🔸 , this is a reasonable flag. This particular assumption is a judgment call that seemed reasonable to us and in line with what we thought a 30% loss in European yields might deliver (this would be quite a large food shock). But happy to update if there were stronger priors. Most importantly, however, most of the harm from AMOC comes from the damage streams in lower-income areas, so even if we were to significantly reduce our parameter here, our topline estimate wouldn’t move much (to the point of it being almost trivial).
Thanks, Tom. That makes sense. You estimate the deaths from "Stream 2 — N/W Africa + South Asia (monsoon disruption)" are 41.8 (= 16.7/0.4) times the deaths from "Stream 1 — N. & W. Europe (cooling-driven yield loss)". I had noted the vast majority of deaths came from stream 2, but should have mentioned it in my comment. I think judgement calls made in one part of the model offer a bit of evidence about ones made in other parts. However, I see now that your assumption to model the deaths from stream 2 that the share of people with food insecurity would increse by 13 pp if AMOC collapsed is much less of a judgement call. From the cell notes here:
I wonder whether the association from Randell et al. (2022) would hold after controlling for temperature. If not, and AMOC's collapse is expected to change the temperature in the relevant regions of stream 2 less than the temperature difference between the 10th percentile and mean rainfall, it could be that the result from Randell et al. (2022) should be adjusted downwards.
Thanks Vasco, good q. I’m not too worried about temperature, since some of their specifications control for it (though we haven’t gone back and checked the 13 pp precisely). I think the stronger critique here is prolly on external validity grounds. On what basis do we go from one extreme year in Tanzania to a sustained 10-30% drop over many years in other regions? There are arguments that cut both ways on whether a persistent shift like this is worse or better than a one-off shock. We say worse in part because we see less potential for adaptation to a long-term weather-induced shock than to a price shock. But who knows, and I think that our note calling our estimate “likely conservative” probably overstates our stance. I’d say it's maybe more of a best guess than a conservative one.
On the practical end of things, as we both have flagged, this damage stream is responsible for most of the harm, so small changes here will tend to generate moderate/large changes in the overall picture. (Not fatally direction-wise though.) I think that looking back, we should have flagged this as a particularly sensitive parameter. But in our defense, we do say we have only medium confidence in this BOTEC because of the long causal chain to mortality, which this parameter belongs to.
Thanks. Makes sense.