EA is full of judgment: this cause area is high impact, this event produced a lot of value, that one not so much, the future will be great in expectation, this person is promising, I’m not doing enough. And so on.
The issue is: I don’t really like judgments. In fact, I have done a lot of work to move away from them, and to move closer to actual experience, to presence, to immediacy. I enjoyed that party. I like looking at you. I tensed up when you said that. I sense some anger in you. And to be honest, that has served me incredibly well. My relationships have improved. I live life more fully. I am more in touch with myself and the world. It’s great.
So what gives? What about these EA judgments?
Especially with the judgments about people, when I bring attention to them, I do tense up. There is a bracing there as if I’m anticipating pain. It feels like being punched in the stomach. And that even holds for the positive ones. If that person is promising, what does that mean about me? What if I’m not promising? Oh, they do think I’m promising?! Wait, what if they stop believing that? Ouch.
My sense is that a lot of the judgments that aren’t directly about people are still infected with this kind of thinking, and people know. We are in fact really good at being attuned to these kinds of more subtle judgments. If this cause area is high impact, and I work on this other cause area, does that mean…? It does. You are a bad person. Or at least not really a good person. An NPC. Ouch.
Before I move on, I actually want to be with the pain of all of this. I have seen it in colleagues who have worked themselves ragged because they are just not good enough. It also shows up in the constant self-doubt of whether this is the right thing and in the countless rejections from jobs and fellowships. My housemate even got rejected from a conference. It really fucking hurts to be told these things. Sometimes over and over again. Sometimes by others, and probably even more often by ourselves.
I feel for all the young people that get sucked into this judgment vortex that makes it so tempting to turn against yourself. I regret the extent to which I have contributed to this. And there is pain in that, too. Thinking back to the times that I have sat in judgment over other people, it does feel like I have had to dissociate from my humanity to some extent to do it. Part of me goes cold when I hear the question: what do you think of that person? I’m not connected to them as a person and only connected to them as a cog in the impact machine. And that sucks.
So far, so normal for a moralistic community. EA can be particularly harsh though. For one, it grades people on a curve which can make it difficult to ever feel like you’re enough. There’s always this other person who’s higher impact. For two, not being high impact means not just feeling worthless, but also possibly losing your job, your friends, or at least their respect, and so on.
Tapping into this pain, I also become confronted with a lot of fear and intense anxiety. What if those things are true about me? Oof. I am good friends with a version of this fear. It makes me want to hide myself, become small, believe what others believe, do the safe thing. Lest I am deemed inferior, not worth investing into. Ouch.
This fear makes it hard for me to stand up for anything because all of me is on the line. Which means I better not step out of it. I worry that this structurally makes it harder for EA to pursue the truth because I’d bend it in a heartbeat if it means I can be okay. I’m okay, right?
I have certainly seen this in my own case. I’d rather defer than be proven bad. I considered posting this under a pseudonym because it means I might escape the judgment of this community. I have applied for jobs because others would think highly of me, so I can think highly of myself. Reading this back makes me tear up.
On a deeper level, all of this has contributed to disconnecting myself from my own wants. And that is probably the most tragic thing of all. To be clear, this was already an issue I had before effective altruism entered my life. But, again, I fear for all the young people who arrive in this community before they had a real chance to get to know themselves, who already have an overfunctioning mind compared to the rest of themselves, and who end up substituting an ideology and the views of others around them for what they actually care about.
To be fair, EA knows this on some level. It’s why people have written about how EA can actually be an exciting opportunity instead of an obligation and why so many love the Replacing Guilt series (including myself). However, I also get the sense that it’s underappreciated how deep the effects actually run. For instance, most posts on epistemic deferral treat it as a question of what people should do: when and how much to defer (e.g., here and here). Some briefly name social pressure as a failure mode, but I don’t think they grapple sufficiently with the fear underneath. And maybe that’s not their job, but I expect that it will be hard to change anything about the level of deferral in EA without deeply understanding the underlying reasons for it. And I expect those to be largely about fear and other emotions rather than disagreements about the optimal policy. The same could be said about other things that require you to step out of line and into the line of fire: starting new organizations and projects, advocating for a new cause area, criticizing established beliefs, and so on.
So what’s the answer? I don’t really know. I’m only now finding my own path because it’s taken me a long time to pry myself even just a little bit free from the judgmental tentacles of effective altruism.
Personally, I have found freedom in being able to see through judgments to the person behind them, in being able to see myself more clearly, and in learning to be okay without being useful or having an impact. I think all of these point toward becoming more whole, and each person has to find their own way there. Mine was through practices like Nonviolent Communication, circling, meditation, therapy, and coaching.
Over time, I have also become more excited to orient myself to truth rather than the good (whatever that is). Truth obviously can come with its own set of judgments. You should believe that, you are wrong about this, I should be better at forecasting, she is smart, he’s a bit sloppy in his reasoning. They can also make me wince in the same way, especially the judgments about people. Being with them without crumbling, on some level, still requires the ability to see through them, to see yourself clearly, and to be okay regardless. At the same time, something about them does feel different to me. They feel a little bit less sharp. I imagine they are closer to something I can see directly, or at least catch a glimpse of. They are less abstracted, less filtered through the meaning-making of another person who wants to feel okay (though there is still some of that!). I also get more of a sense that we’re on the same team somehow? Or at least that we could be. That feels less obvious to me with the judgments around the good.
And I have this fantasy that if I can just see myself and the world clearly, I will be able to discern the right actions and pursue them effortlessly and without contorting myself. But what are the right actions you ask? Surely, that requires some standard of the good. Maybe. But I am not so sure. I have come to trust more and more that there is a natural caring in me that wants to find expression, and my job is primarily to just get out of the way.
Thanks for writing this, Stefan. I relate to a lot of what you've written and have spent much of this year reflecting on similar questions. It's interesting that you have found joy in orientating towards Truth instead of the Good because in my journey this year, I've found a lot of peace from orientating to the third member of the traditional trio: Beauty.
I've spent a lot of time wondering whether EA is somewhere I want to be. Can I contribute? Do I even want to contribute? Wouldn't I be happier if I thought smaller and more in the everyday? But I keep coming back to the fact that I find EA beautiful.
Not beautiful in the visual sense, or because everything EAs do is good. Rather, there's something profoundly moving about people voluntarily turning their attention away from themselves and towards the suffering and flourishing of beings they'll never meet. With a cultural discipline that seems less likely than other do-gooding movements to descend into soggy Romantic idealism - with sweeping claims and abstract nouns instead of a focus on the details and quantification.
I feel lucky that I found EA a wee bit older, when I was already quite jaded and cynical. Perhaps I'm just a typical Gen Z, but I thought really trying was a bit cringe. Where you describe bracing yourself in anticipation of pain, I think I'd simply come to regard pain and disappointment as the default, I'd accepted "The Truth" and become desensitised. What's the point of putting your heart into something that's unlikely to work? LDAR.
Many EAs could devote their intelligence, energy and ambition to making comfortable, interesting lives for themselves. They could pursue creative or competitive hobbies, spend more time with their families, and generally enjoy being alive. Some people would be doing EA style work either way, they are really sensitive to the ugliness of the work and wouldn't consider spending their life doing anything else. Yet there are others choose to concern themselves with problems they could quite easily ignore, with an awareness that their best intentions might achieve very little, or even make things worse but they try anyway.
The choice to do this is so beautiful, partly because it's fragile and has to be made again and again 🥹
--
Anyway that's a bit soppy, some reading for those who might be interested in this:
--
Wishing you well!
I do also find a lot of beauty and reverence when opening my mind to all that is EA. Thanks for putting that into words!
Also, Iris Murdoch recently made it onto my book stack! Thanks for the other recs, too :)
Thanks for sharing this. I found it powerful as a description of your experience.
But beyond that, I'm feeling like this is getting at something at the heart of what EA is, or should be, or something:
You're presenting this (extremely legitimately!) in terms of personal experience + orientation. But I have some sense that maybe a lot of times when EA (as a social phenomenon) is going well, it's often because the people involved are locally quite truth-oriented; and when it's going poorly, it's often because the people involved are locally quite good-oriented at the expense of truth-orientation.
And like -- in fact both are important. Broader society could do with a lot more impact-orientation! But within EA circles I think that people would often do well to trust that the participants will all basically want to do good things, and that therefore this is an environment where it's best not to steer from their own models of what's good (let alone someone else's!), and instead to show up as something like an honest epistemic broker, pursuing truth and helping others in that pursuit.
(Conscious I'm again speaking to how it might be nice if people behaved instead of really meeting where people are at; offering the thoughts in case others can build off them.)
>But I have some sense that maybe a lot of times when EA (as a social phenomenon) is going well, it's often because the people involved are locally quite truth-oriented; and when it's going poorly, it's often because the people involved are locally quite good-oriented at the expense of truth-orientation.
I agree with this and had briefly thought about including something like this in the post. I thought of GiveWell as a prime positive example of this kind of thing.
Thanks for the post. I appreciate the thoughtfulness, honesty, and self reflection.
One thing I think the post doesn't articulate enough is tradeoffs - what is gained and lost by rejecting status games and judgment. All else equal it would be better having less of these things. The way you describe them. They sound so obviously bad and destructive but I worry that sometimes it's harder to not throw out the baby with the bathwater than it seems.
For example I like the idea that wherever you go there will always be status games, so it's best to find people who reward you for playing status games that you want to play, like being truth-seeking or trying to do the most good. Then, for example, who has the most money or is the most fashionable?
Another thing that might be lost is the good done to help beneficiaries. I see in some circles a focus and valorisation of working on yourself as an important first step before helping others. But I wonder how true this is. Claude tells me LBJ was motivated by a fear of humiliation, Hamilton was vdery sensitive to slights related to his poor origins, Darwin was anxious about someone else beating him in publishing similar works.
If it is the case that focusing on ourselves more, or worrying about status less, or focusing more on the truth, comes at a cost to 'the good', this seems very grave indeed, and I'd argue we should move with great caution (not to say doing good is the only thing that should matter to any of us). If the two are always aligned, then this is very interesting as well, but I'd want to see it argued more clearly. Curious what you think.
>One thing I think the post doesn't articulate enough is tradeoffs - what is gained and lost by rejecting status games and judgment. All else equal it would be better having less of these things. The way you describe them. They sound so obviously bad and destructive but I worry that sometimes it's harder to not throw out the baby with the bathwater than it seems.
I worry that the trade-off language smuggles in a way of relating to all this that this other orientation just rejects. And as a result I feel a bit lost.
And don't get me wrong, the he "EA" part of me is like: "Yeah, how good is this orientation for maximizing the good in the world? What are the trade-offs here? You're dodging the hard bit."
And the part that wrote the post is a bit like (toward my own voice, not you): "What the fuck?! I just told you I don't like these judgments, and that they're toxic and corrosive, and here you are coming in with them through the backdoor again. Don't tell me how I should be in pursuit of this thing that you have elevated above all else, including yourself."
I'm not sure if a resolution is a possible. They just seem like fundamentally different ways of orienting to the world, and your self. And I don't know if there is a perspective above them that can make them commensurate somehow. I do know that I do not want to privilege the "EA"/"maximizing" perspective as a default (which I've done for a long time).
Maybe we(/you) can let both voices have a seat at the table?
Very much guesswork / projection from my own experiences navigating internal frictions and what worked for me, but I want to say something like:
Obviously your mileage may vary!
What Owen said resonates. A few things I want to add:
When you say "I do know that I do not want to privilege the "EA"/"maximizing" perspective as a default", combined with reading this post, I'm curious whether (a) this post is an attempt to give space to the non-maximising part to express himself, even though out in everyday life he is not always in control, (b) this part is in fact now in control, so this post represents what 'you' currently endorse, or (c) other?
If the answer is (b), I appreciate this seems like a good approach for someone who is too deep down the rabbit hole of EA, EA status games, judgment, etc, and would benefit from stepping out of it a bit.
But, for many people, I feel totally comfortable encouraging them to think more about the suffering of others, and effectiveness, and that it's okay to try and improve the world even if part of the motivation is guilt and status because the world is on fire and we don't need everyone to be enlightened before they can help, we need people to help put out fires.
Hi Stefan. I liked this post.
This was touching and I appreciate your sincerity. I feel EA also needs these emotional expressions to complement the rational input that drives the community.
I think there is not an "absolute high-impact cause" for everyone. A cause can be great to commit for someone based on personal fit, and horrible for other person, even if it is the same "high impact" cause.
Same logic to apply for judgments. A person is not "high potential" in absolute terms, is "high potential for X skill, for Y cause, for Z project", and probably bad for others because there are negative-correlated capabilities.
Practising contextualizing and relativizing our communication could be great for EA, so more sensitive people feel welcomed and embraced by this community.
Compassion and emotions are one essential part of humanity, so thanks for expressing all this. =)