Hide table of contents

We’re the co-founders of Better Futures Guide (BFG), a charity evaluator specifically focused on livelihoods. We were founded last year through Ambitious Impact’s Charity Entrepreneurship Incubation Program. We welcome questions, criticism and opportunities for collaboration, in the comments or at [email protected].

Summary

  • Better Futures Guide is a new charity evaluator focused on livelihoods: programs that work with people living in poverty to increase their incomes and what they can provide for themselves and their families. Our research and recommendations are public.
  • Our first recommendation is in "poverty graduation”,  an approach that gives households a bundle of support for roughly 1-2 years, on the premise that households are more likely to exit extreme poverty in a durable way when several of their constraints are addressed at once.
    • Poverty graduation has been tested for nearly two decades. In a recent meta-analysis of 40 randomized trials in 26 countries, graduation programs raised consumption (what a household eats and uses) by about 11%, income by 15% and assets by 40% on average.
  • Unconditional cash transfers, such as GiveDirectly’s, are a popular choice within effective giving. Recent, low-cost graduation programs can be more cost-effective. Earlier, more expensive graduation programs usually were not.
  • Our first recommended charity is: Raising The Village, which runs a two-year graduation program for whole villages in Uganda, Rwanda, the DRC and Tanzania.
  • Our analysis finds Raising The Village to be highly cost-effective. We estimate it delivers the equivalent of doubling one person’s consumption[1] for a year for about $27, which by our calculation is ~6x as cost-effective as GiveDirectly and ~11x GiveWell’s benchmark.

  • Raising The Village aims to grow from serving 1 million people in 2026 to about 2 million in 2027. It can absorb millions in additional funding at the cost-effectiveness we’ve modeled.

Introduction

Hi all, we’re Better Futures Guide, a new charity evaluator focused on livelihoods. We find and recommend nonprofits that reduce global poverty by working with people to increase their incomes and consumption (such as of food, shelter, medical care, and school fees).

We work the way many evaluators do. First, we identify a type of program with a strong evidence base. Then we find well-managed organizations that carry it out in high-impact, cost-effective ways. In practice, that means months of desk research, dozens of conversations with experts, and in-depth discussions with charities on their responses to our questions and data requests. Our recommendations, and the research behind them, are public.

A little about us: Co-founder Rens Bakker worked for nine years at the national government of the Netherlands on labor market and livelihood reforms. Co-founder Elizabeth Weissberg spent fifteen years in research and communications, including at the Aspen Institute and Yale’s Social, Cognitive, and Affective Neuroscience Lab. Aqsa Zaidi, our research fellow, is an MA student at Georgetown with nine prior years of experience in education and development. We’re driven to do this work for many reasons, including that more than 800 million people live on less than $3[2] a day, and that there is strong evidence on how to change that.

This year we focused on three areas within livelihoods: poverty graduation, foundational learning, and cross-border livelihoods. Our first recommendation, below, is in poverty graduation. We’ll share more recommendations as we finish each.

What is poverty graduation?

The premise: address several constraints at once

Poverty graduation is a type of program built on the premise that individuals and families remain in extreme poverty because they face several constraints at once. For instance, a family may have no money to invest, little access to training in farming or business skills, and no savings to absorb a setback, such as a failed harvest or an illness. Graduation programs therefore address these constraints together, typically over one to two years, with the aim that households sustain a higher living standard after the program ends.

Not every graduation program has identical components. However, to be included in the meta-analysis mentioned above, a program combined at least three of these five[3]:

  • A transfer of cash or productive goods, such as tools or equipment, which provides the means to start or expand an income-earning activity
  • Training, for example in farming, livestock care or business skills, to earn more from that activity
  • Consumption support: smaller transfers of cash or food that cover basic needs while the activity becomes established
  • Coaching: recurring visits or group meetings to apply trainings and resolve problems as they arise
  • Savings support, often through a savings group or an account, to build a reserve for emergencies

The approach was pioneered in 2002 and is among the best-evidenced ways to reduce extreme poverty. In a recent meta-analysis of 40 randomized trials in 26 countries, graduation programs raised consumption (what a person eats and uses) by about 11%, income by 15% and assets by 40% on average. Most trials measured effects up to four years after programs ended, and across them consumption gains were on average as large or larger at later measurements.[4] 

Comparison with unconditional cash transfers

Graduation programs and unconditional cash transfers both aim to reduce extreme poverty. Many livelihoods-oriented donors currently give to GiveDirectly, which sends unconditional cash transfers. Depending on a donor's priorities (e.g., immediate freedom of choice), this may be the most values-aligned donation. However, for donors more interested in the size of income or consumption gains per dollar, we think that graduation programs have the potential to be substantially more cost-effective.

Graduation rests on the idea of a ‘big push’ out of extreme poverty: support on several fronts at once, substantial enough for households to raise their living standard durably. That is why programs combine the components described above. In graduation programs started since 2016, the median program cost is about $520 per household, about a third less than earlier programs.[5]

In comparison, unconditional cash typically involves a larger transfer and few or no other components. In GiveWell’s model of GiveDirectly’s Cash for Poverty Relief program, the transfer itself is about $865 to $1,100 per household (2024 US dollars), depending on the country.[6] Because households consume most of the transfer in the first year, about 42-45% of the consumption gain to recipients falls in the first year, and 68-70% within three years.[7] In contrast, our model of Raising The Village’s graduation program shows gains that are more evenly spread and longer-lasting.

In practice, some graduation and cash programs are starting to look more alike. Graduation programs are becoming lower-cost and more similar to cash transfers, while GiveDirectly is experimenting with incorporating aspects of the graduation approach. In graduation programs, the main transfer is now most often a lump sum of cash rather than a physical asset such as livestock, and costs have fallen as implementers sought lower-cost designs and governments took programs on. GiveDirectly, for its part, now pairs its cash transfers with light-touch coaching and savings support. It is also testing whether adding training and behavioral support to large transfers can match graduation programs at lower cost.

The academic literature suggests that recent graduation programs can be more cost-effective than unconditional cash transfers, provided the costs are low. The aforementioned meta-analysis[8] found that graduation typically outperforms cash when looking at programs started since 2016, but usually not in earlier cases, when programs were more expensive. Two earlier meta-analyses found that graduation programs or graduation-inspired additions to cash programs lead to larger impact than unconditional cash transfers, but that this is cost-effective compared to unconditional cash transfers only in specific circumstances.[9]

Overall, we think graduation programs that are well designed, well run and low cost have the potential to be substantially more cost-effective than unconditional cash transfers.

Our recommendation: Raising The Village

As mentioned above, graduation programs differ in cost and in results, so the impact of a donation depends on which organization receives it. Raising The Village runs an unusually low-cost version of poverty graduation. Yet, as we discuss below, a randomized trial found its effects on par with higher-cost programs, and in the meta-analysis referenced above, its trial had the highest benefit-cost ratio of 43 program arms.[10],[11] As we also discuss below, it met our other criteria for a recommendation: it has substantial room for more funding, has sound organizational capacity, and was able to provide us with the detailed cost and monitoring data our evaluation required.[12]

Description of activities

Raising The Village works in remote farming villages in Uganda, Rwanda, the DRC and Tanzania. These villages have few roads, clinics, or other services, and families rely on what they grow for both food and income. Even just after harvest, more than half of households live on less than $3 per person per day (PPP). Its program is structured as follows:

  • Pre-planning. Raising The Village selects villages in coordination with the local government. Its staff then map and survey households, ask the village to list its needs, and select seed packages for later distribution based on local climate data and meetings with households.
  • Core implementation (months 0–6). Households receive the seed packages, and the village receives shared farming equipment, such as a milling machine, spray pumps, water drums, wheelbarrows, and other tools. Households attend training sessions covering topics such as agricultural practices, savings groups, and budgeting. The village elects volunteer committees who receive extra training on a specific topic, mentor their peers, and look after shared equipment.
  • Transition (months 7–12). Each quarter, independent data collectors survey a sample of households to check whether at least 90% are using the practices they were trained in. Villages below that level receive extra training and support. Committee members visit every household on a fixed schedule to provide their peers with support.
  • Community ownership (months 12–24). Volunteer committees take over more of the day-to-day work, such as mentoring neighbors and managing shared tools. Staff shift from delivery to mentoring and then handover, providing refresher trainings where the data show a need. At month 24, the village graduates.
  • Follow-up (months 25–60). Program activity ends. To inform future program design, Raising The Village surveys a sample of households each year until five years after the start of the program to track metrics including income, production, assets, and food security.

Most graduation programs target the poorest households in a village. Raising The Village instead works with every household, and actively involves community volunteers in its programming. According to its theory of change, this provides multiple benefits simultaneously:

  • New practices spread. New practices – e.g., for increasing yields or saving money – spread through the community via shared learning and peer accountability.
  • Downsides of household targeting are bypassed. The program does not have to select households within a community in which even better-off households tend to be poor. Selecting households can be costly, error-prone, and perceived as unfair.
  • Costs are lower. Training can be given to groups, volunteers can mentor neighbors, and no money is spent on deciding which households are eligible.

Raising The Village reached 647,000 people in 2025, 1 million in 2026, and aims to reach about 2 million in 2027. As it grows, it is testing how the program performs in new settings and with new partners. In Rwanda and the DRC, it is currently running deliberately small programs, which it calls Learning Hubs. In Tanzania, its activities launched this year.

Impact

The program has been independently evaluated in a randomized controlled trial (Mahmud and Riley, 2026).[13] The researchers randomly assigned 335 villages and surveyed 3,852 households. About three years after the program began, the trial found the following economic effects in program villages:

  • Income was 26% higher. About half of the gain came from selling more crops, and a third from more households running small businesses.
  • Wealth in livestock, savings and household goods was 31% higher.
  • Consumption (what a household eats and uses) was 10% higher just after harvest, and 39% higher in the “lean season”, the months leading up to a harvest when food stores run low and households are hungriest.

These gains showed up in daily life. In the lean season, 25% of households in villages without the program said a child had gone to bed hungry during the past month. In program villages, it was 4%. For adults, the figures were 38% and 6%.

Gains reached households at every level. The poorest quarter of households gained about as much in dollars as other households, which meant their gain was larger in proportion: their income was 41% higher than that of the poorest quarter of households in comparison villages. Serving every household did not come at the expense of those with the least.

These results are similar to the average effect of graduation programs in the recent meta-analysis, yet at about a third of the median cost of programs started since 2016[14].  Because of this notable cost-effectiveness, we have taken extra care to verify the plausibility of Mahmud and Riley’s results. Our conclusion, based on the trial’s quality, the wider graduation literature, and outside experts, is that we find the trial’s results plausible. 

Also, in addition to its whole-village model being lower-cost than household-based targeting,[15] we found Raising The Village to be an exceptionally data-driven organization. Its Annual Household Survey follows a random sample of households in each program village from baseline through year five, with the same survey administered in comparable non-program villages; its 2025 Impact Report draws on about 42,000 households in 1,575 villages. Leadership reviews program data quarterly and decides on changes for the following quarter. In 2024, for example, after cohort data showed consistently low income from perennial crops such as coffee, it introduced training in their cultivation. In the first cohort trained, Raising The Village’s monitoring data show per-household income from perennials rising from $23 at baseline to $102 a year later.

Cost-effectiveness

As part of our evaluation, we built a cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) of Raising The Village: a model that estimates the impact of a donation made in 2027 or 2028 relative to its cost. We measure impact in consumption doublings: one doubling is the equivalent of doubling one person’s consumption for one year.

Our findings:

  • Raising The Village achieves one consumption doubling for an estimated $27.
  • It is ~6x as cost-effective as cash transfers from GiveDirectly, on an estimated like-for-like basis.[16]

  • By our calculations, that is ~11x GiveWell’s benchmark, excluding health impacts that we did not model but that Raising The Village is likely to cause.

We have published an interactive, schematic version of our CEA on our website, where you can adjust our assumptions and see the effect on our estimate.

Our CEA has five main components:

  • Effect. We take the randomized trial’s effect on household consumption, measured separately just after harvest and in the months before the next one, when the effect was nearly four times larger. We then adjust both figures to account for the limits of evidence from a single trial.
  • Persistence. The trial followed households for about three years. We model seven scenarios for how long the effect lasts beyond that, each weighted by how well it fits the program’s design, its own monitoring data and long-run studies of other graduation programs.
  • Applicability. We adjust the trial’s results for each country, to reflect changes to the program since the trial and differences between Uganda, where the trial took place, and the other three countries. We also subtract the value that government contributions to the program would have had elsewhere.
  • Cost. We take Raising The Village’s projected cost per participant in 2027–28 in each of its four countries, adjusted upward because, across organizations in general, actual costs tend to exceed projections.
  • Simulations. We run our model 10,000 times, each time drawing a different plausible value for every uncertain input. The four inputs that move our estimate most are how long the effect lasts, the size of the effect in the months before harvest, how well the trial’s results apply to the program as it runs today. We have built each of these into the model. In 80% of our simulations, the cost per consumption doubling fell between $16 and $62, with half falling below about $30. Raising The Village was more cost-effective than our like-for-like GiveDirectly estimate in more than 99% of our simulations.

We are not the first evaluator to look at Raising The Village. Founders Pledge and The Life You Can Save already recommend it, and GiveWell has published a back-of-the-envelope calculation (BOTEC) and is funding further research into its impact.[17] However, to our knowledge, we are the first evaluator to publish an extensive cost-effectiveness analysis of it, based on the most recent academic evidence.

Room for more funding and organizational capacity

Alongside cost-effectiveness, we assess room for more funding and organizational capacity, including ability to scale.

With regards to funding, Raising The Village reported a funding gap of between $8 million and tens of millions of dollars a year in the growth scenarios it shared with us, and our full evaluation indicates it can use additional donations at the cost-effectiveness we have modeled.

Raising The Village is scaling quickly and aims to reach about 2 million people in 2027, up from 647,000 in 2025. This kind of growth will require it to adapt its management structure, among other things. Its growth also relies on increased government involvement, which can pose risks for implementation fidelity. In our full technical report, we discuss why we believe that Raising The Village can sustain the cost-effectiveness we have modeled as it grows.  

If you’d like to donate

You can donate to Raising The Village here. If you are considering a larger gift or advise donors, we’re happy to discuss our research further: [email protected].

Next steps for Better Futures Guide

In addition to our poverty graduation work, the next sectors we’ll release recommendations in are foundational learning and cross-border livelihoods.

We’re constantly looking for ways to maximize our own impact, and we welcome ideas, feedback, and proposals for collaboration. We’d also be grateful for introductions to funders and advisors who are active in this space. Please reach out to us at [email protected].

Better Futures Guide has received funding from the Livelihood Impact Fund (LIF), which is Raising The Village’s largest funder. We conduct our work independently from LIF, although its staff has provided us with valuable input and feedback.

We use Claude to assist our research and drafting process. All views, and the primary and final drafting of this post, are ours.

 

  1. ^

     Consumption is the value of everything a household eats and uses, including food it grows itself. For households in extreme poverty it reflects living standards better than income, because much of what they produce is consumed instead of turned into income.

  2. ^

     The often-quoted $3 poverty line is in 2021 international dollars: incomes are converted using purchasing power parities, so that $3 buys in each country roughly what it bought in the United States in 2021.

  3. ^

     In the meta-analysis, programs with all five components tended to have larger effects on economic outcomes. No single component stood out as either essential or unnecessary (Carter et al. 2026, section 4.2). See our technical report for further discussion.

  4. ^

     Some trials found little or no effect. In several of these, the program did not run as planned because of conflict or operational problems. In others, living standards also rose among comparison households, which narrowed the gap (Carter et al. 2026, section 4.1.1). Please see our technical report for an overview of the evidence.

  5. ^

     Our calculation, from Carter et al. (2026), Data Appendix Tables 1 and 3: the median cost of the 31 program arms started since 2016 is $415 per household in 2020 dollars, or about $520 in January 2026 dollars.

  6. ^

     GiveWell’s 2024 cost-effectiveness analysis of GiveDirectly: the transfer per household in each of the five countries it models, from $865 in Kenya to $1,100 in Rwanda.

  7. ^

     Our calculation from GiveWell’s model, across its five countries, with future gains discounted at 4% a year. Some studies have identified longer-term impacts, including in Kenya (early results, not yet published) and Uganda (Fiala et al. 2025).

  8. ^
  9. ^
  10. ^

     Mahmud and Riley (2026), discussed under “Impact” below.

  11. ^

    Carter et al. (2026), Data Appendix Table 4.

  12. ^

     On our selection process: Raising The Village appeared in our desk research, a list of about 400 organizations running some 550 programs, compiled from practitioner networks, funder portfolios and the World Bank’s survey of economic inclusion programs. It then passed our filtering criteria, which include operating in regions where extreme poverty is concentrated and its specific program being supported by evidence from a randomized trial. When we then asked experts for nominations, several named it, citing its cost-effectiveness, use of data and organizational capacity. As a last step before inviting organizations for evaluation, we built rough cost-effectiveness estimates for the most promising candidates. No rough estimate can establish which program is the single "most" cost-effective, but Raising The Village was clearly in the top tier. Our full evaluation then allowed us to develop that initial estimate in depth, and confirm that it met our other criteria: room for more funding, demonstrated organizational capacity, and a willingness to provide detailed cost and monitoring data during our evaluation cycle’s timeline. Other poverty graduation organizations also look promising, and we will likely evaluate them in later rounds as our capacity allows.

  13. ^
  14. ^

     Our calculation. Raising The Village’s projected cost in Uganda in 2027–28 is about $32 per person, or about $161 per household of 4.98 people. The median cost of the 31 graduation program arms started since 2016 is $415 per household in 2020 dollars, or about $520 in January 2026 dollars (Carter et al. 2026, Data Appendix Tables 1 and 3). Cost projection: Raising The Village, answers to our questions, October 2026.

  15. ^

     Raising The Village is unique in its village-based approach. In our evaluation report, we discuss why we still consider it a graduation program, and why we consider the overall academic literature on poverty graduation applicable to Raising The Village.

  16. ^

    We compare our estimate with GiveWell’s 2024 analysis of GiveDirectly’s Cash for Poverty Relief program. Because the Raising The Village trial compared whole clusters of villages, its estimate already includes gains that pass between neighbors. To make the comparison like-for-like, we count cash’s gains to recipients plus 37% of GiveWell’s modeled gains to non-recipients, an estimate based on Egger et al. (2022). Counted this way, cash costs $151 per consumption doubling. Counting the direct recipients’ gains alone, the figure is $185. Raising The Village remains 3.5 times as cost-effective even when all of cash’s spillovers and health effects are counted ($95 per doubling) and none of its own beyond the cluster. Please see our technical report for further discussion.

  17. ^

     GiveWell funded a five-year follow-up of the trial in November 2024, and in 2026 made grants for a new randomized trial of Raising The Village’s program in Uganda, listed in its grants database. A further trial, in the DRC, is planned for 2028 and still at the concept stage.

  18. Show all footnotes

49

3
0
2

Reactions

3
0
2

More posts like this

Comments
No comments on this post yet.
Be the first to respond.
Curated and popular this week
Relevant opportunities