EB

Evan Boyar

Head of Technology @ New Roots Institute
18 karmaJoined New York, NY, USA

Participation
2

  • Attended more than three meetings with a local EA group
  • Attended an EA Global conference

Comments
6

On the value of experience bit, the pain without "discomfort, distraction, or desire for relief" seems completely different from pain that is not remembered. Many would say it's unlikely pain is remembered after death, yet most would say that doesn't change whether or not it matters.

Is your model of how people would be offsetting one in which they are calculating it prior to picking up the product from the shelf (or at least prior to buying it at the store)? That's not really how the few people who do animal product offsets appear to be doing it: from what I've seen they generally assess their level of consumption and then purchase set-it-and-forget-it recurring offsets, to be reevaluated at most yearly. Crucially they're seeing how much they consume and then purchasing offsets.

Meat offsets probably do reduce meat consumption

On the other hand, meat offsets are a direct cost to the meat eater. They are increasing the cost of meat to that consumer.

I'd be surprised if offset costs[1] not incurred at the point of sale meaningfully impacted consumption. People respond far less to fees when they're less salient at the point of sale.[2]

  1. ^

    ...of a similar magnitude to the ones suggested by Farmkind, for example. If offset costs were, conversely, large enough to require someone to mortgage their home in order to eat a slice of pecorino, you'd see an effect

  2. ^

    See also:
    Chetty, Looney & Kroft (2009, AER): Including taxes in the price shown in stores decreased consumption (n.b. for non-Americans, in the US, store sales prices do not general display the price inclusive of taxes), even though people were paying the same price!

    Finkelstein (2009, QJE): When toll roads were converted from manual (i.e. you have to physically fork over money to get through a toll) to automatic (i.e. you're just charged after the fact by your license plate/a radio transponder), people increased their use of toll roads

Through the ancient art of "multiplication" we can see how important it is to stop the current situation where trillions are being tortured to death.

My antennae are waving with excitement. Big (larger than 20 cm) things are coming!

These bivalves lack pain receptors and central nervous systems

The article you link doesn't make one of the two claims you make: that they lack pain receptors. Indeed, there is evidence of oyster nociception.