FTS

Forge the Sky

1 karmaJoined

Comments
13

Forge the Sky
1
0
0
50% agree

Understanding how LLMs learn (e.g. SLT) is underrated relative to work on instilling specific behaviors

By analogy, this is like the difference between understanding how to make humans not suffer from the foibles of human nature, rather than the very brittle and incomplete methods of culture, religion, and ideology.  Make something not even have evil nature first!

Forge the Sky
1
0
0
60% disagree

We are making good progress in the AI S-risk space and research is on track

I don't really see it much in the discourse at all; if it isn't by this stage, it's going to be hard to catch up.                                                                         

Forge the Sky
1
0
1
40% agree

Increased care by AIs for some kinds of entities will have substantial spillovers to other kinds (e.g. humans to digital minds and vice versa)

Humans, at least, tend to learn empathy and have it encouraged and reinforced by example.  Humans will mirror AI's; AI's will learn from each other. 

Forge the Sky
2
2
0
30% agree

Theories of consciousness will lead to actionable understanding of AI consciousness²

Yes, though I think the direction will far more go the opposite way - that is, AI conciousness, if it emerges, will still more help us understand consciousness.

Forge the Sky
1
0
0
20% agree

The backfire risks of AI values alignment outweigh the expected positives

Fairly uncertain here, though I don't see any way of continuing to make systems better without trying for value alignment. A dangerous situation. 

Forge the Sky
1
1
1
40% agree

Current AIs are capable of suffering

Recursive thinking loops possibly put current systems into a state of transient quasi-awareness; once this exists, the capacity for suffering becomes inevitable in any system with incentives. 

Forge the Sky
1
0
0
40% disagree

Benchmarks will become useless due to eval awareness¹

Though they will need much more careful design, done along with careful understanding of incentives alignment, techniques such as competitive benchmarks will continue to have some utility.

Forge the Sky
1
0
0
30% disagree

If animals continue to exist in a post-AGI world, animal suffering will not persist

If animals persist, it is likely we would like them to remain to some degree of their nature; prosperity and control will likely allow for substantial reduction of suffering but not elimination.