Hide table of contents

Context: WelfareTech

There has been some concern lately about effective altruism's supposed turn away from diet change, systemic shift, animal liberation, etc. As far as I can tell, this is due to 1) a widely reshared Substack article which got some praise from EA-aligned folks, including folks at @Coefficient Giving; 2) the fact that Innovate Animal Ag is setting up an "accelerator farm," which, per Robert Yaman, will be "a commercial broiler facility that sells chickens into the market, but it will also be a place where startups can test technologies and where we can combine interventions;" and 3) the emergence of Spring Innovation Fund, which launched this summer as "a not-for-profit venture philanthropy studio and fund built specifically for Welfare Tech: technology that improves animal welfare in ways that make commercial sense for producers to adopt."

I don't buy it

I just got back from two EA events (the Communicators Retreat and EAG NYC) where I talked to a few dozen people at length. Almost everyone wanted to talk about diet change and animal liberation. I think this supposed turn away from these topics has been greatly exaggerated. The EA rank and file want to see animals liberated from human oppression and/or living in nature. 

This impression is probably colored by who I am and therefore who wants to talk to me. On the other hand, the people who write publicly about this and/or start funds to promote Welfare Tech are also clearly not a random sample either.

Maybe the elites are doing an about-face and the rest of us will follow their marching orders once the money comes in?

Insofar as effective animal advocacy has an inner cabal, I talk to them pretty regularly. I don't think they've given up on diet change. @LewisBollard writes that EA "deprioritized it based on evidence it wasn't working." Deprioritized is not giving up. If something promising (re: novel) and/or evidence-backed came up, I think people would be into it. For what it's worth, I received (directly or indirectly) four instances of solidly EA-flavored funding to do diet change research in 2026. But we’re not going to leap to support leaflets or digital advocacy or whatever. Not without reasonable evidence that it'll work better than it did in the past. 

Why did this consensus emerge?

My going theory is that too few effective animal advocates write about what they're thinking and doing for the public. @Aidan Kankyoku's post reverberated in part because he's one of the few of us doing this.[1] Outliers are taken as representative because normies are silent.

Solution: more of us should write more and more hastily

Posting in public is fun, it might be good for your career, and it has the nice property of also giving external audiences a more accurate read on EA thinking. Effective Altruism is good. Let's tell people about it, and not let a few loudmouths (me included) speak for the community. 

Moreover, animal people should generally write more slapdashedly. I talked to several people at EAG who were like "oh I have a big backlog of posts I've been meaning to publish" or "I sat on that post for a year because I wasn't sure people wanted to read it." Folks, stop it! Just post, record a 1 minute video on your phone and post it on LinkedIn. Hit the go button. Say "it's 9:55 right now, when the clock strikes 10:30, I'm going to post this no matter what." This is not school, C work that gets published regularly is better than A work that you sit on.

Some tactical remarks

  1. Unless your audience is specifically EAs, as is true for this post, you should not write primarily for the EA forum. Twitter or Substack or Bluesky or podcasts or whatever is where you at least have a chance of achieving escape velocity.
  2. Several people at the Communicators Retreat emphasized that authenticity sells, and when you workshop something to death, you risk losing it. I think this is right. Corollary: don't have AI write your stuff. Authentic and messy is way more appealing.
  3. Posting more could be very good for your career, as it was for mine.

By the way, Meera Zassenhaus makes a similar point in Animal people need to stop lurking and start posting.
 

 

  1. ^

    There are lots of posts arguing that why veganism is good, people who eat meat are bad, etc. I view this work as very likely pointless and likely bad for the cause on net. The vegan echo chamber is a real problem.

Comments6
Sorted by Click to highlight new comments since:

Agree with everything in the body of the post, and my message to folks who feel discouraged by the focus on welfare (tech) would similarly be "If you can demonstrate that you + your TOC are capable of delivering tangible goods w/r/t diet change or culture change, you will probably get funding!"

That said, I think there is some truth to the literal statement "EA has given up on diet change and animal liberation." Not necessarily permanently, and not everyone, but the bar to start/get funding for a new project in these areas is higher after decades of ~null results, and I think it's good for would-be founders to know that.

It's a confusing landscape for people who want to write about dietary change right now.

EA hasn’t given up on dietary change.

Yet

Funding and incubators are springing up around approaches that seem compatible with continued factory farming.

That’s only because

Everyday advocates for dietary change aren’t speaking up enough.

But

If they do, they’d best avoid the ‘vegan echo chamber’

Since

Vegans should be more inclusive of people who aren’t changing their diets.

Even though

EA is still positive about dietary change overall, despite the fact that dietary change has been deprioritised by the biggest (?) funder in the space for not being evidence-based.
 

… It’s hard to strike a balance that doesn’t knock into any of the above while still making a coherent point.

Also, I was at EAG NYC too and, of the 20 or so random ‘what brings you to EAG?’ conversations I had between meetings, not a single person I spoke to was there for animals. Almost all of them were there to ‘find my place in AI safety’, with one person working on GHD.  So that’s my tuppence worth on who seemed to be attending.

Wish I could be more positive, but I think the messaging around veganism has done too much of a U-turn, and it’s going to be hard now to separate that from the perceived view of the movement towards dietary change, since the two are so closely related.

Yeah, when you put it that way, I can see why this might be difficult to navigate. I suppose I'm finding this navigable because the 'diet change' work I do is inherently evaluative -- my projects help funders make decisions about what to fund, rather than asking them to fund a particular TOC. 

Re: EAG NYC: I had a few moments where I wanted the meals to be a bit more segregated, like not to have to try too hard to find the animal people. I agree that AI seems to be getting most of the energy lately. 

Hi Seth.

If something promising (re: novel) and/or evidence-backed came up, I think people would be into it.

Here is a related post from Tom Billington and Henning Peters.

Folks, stop it!

I found this funny.

I live to amuse 🫡 

For those working on diet-change, this is a wonderful example. Perspective on this is that Belgium is not like California. 

There is not a strong vegan movement like in India - this is just a cool city with a strong beer and party culture and a great university. 

But this one city has made some amazing progress on diet-change that we could all learn from. 

What I find interesting about this: This was all achieved without any pressure or guilt. Nobody is being asked to become vegan. There are no vegans looking disapprovingly at anyone eating meat.

People are just being shown the positives, in a positive way "Look at all the amazing, tasty vegan food out there, I bet you didn't know it was that good!" Then they get the feel-good factor of knowing they're also helping improve the world, lower climate impact, less animal suffering - and it's cool and it's all a positive experience. 

Schoolchildren are being exposed to vegan dishes, but not in a political, activist way - nothing that will get parents rebelling. it's all positive. It results in lots of places having vegan options they didn't have before - no pressure to choose them, but many people do. And eventually, many of these people may become vegans. And even if they don't, they will probably consume a lot less meat.

I am obviously not aware of what's happening elsewhere, but this feels like a real win/win approach that could work in any city. Because it's fun, it's exciting, it's novel, it's different. And, as a bonus, it also helps reduce animal suffering. 

Veggie Thursdays and vegan surprises! How Ghent became a plant-based paradise | Food | The Guardian

Curated and popular this week
Relevant opportunities