Hide table of contents

I think the AI bubble is almost certain (~95% likely) to pop within the next ~7 years.[1] I'm looking for anyone in the effective altruism community or AI safety community who is willing to bet against me. Consider betting against me if you believe with high confidence there isn't an AI bubble and that there won't be any AI bubble pop within the next ~7 years.

There is obviously a close connection between the probability of an AI bubble and the trajectory of general capabilities improvement in AI. I have argued that the EA 2.0 community and the AI safety community are vastly overestimating how much general AI capabilities will improve within the next ~5-10 years. A bet on whether there is an AI bubble that will pop sometime within the next ~7 years is an indirect bet on how close we are to artificial general intelligence, transformative AI, existentially dangerous AI, and so on.

I've played around with formulating this bet a few different ways. Here is a formulation that marries elegant simplicity with absolutely unambiguous resolution criteria. None of this is set in stone whatsoever. If you have another idea about how you would like to formulate an AI bubble bet, please make me a counteroffer.

Stakes

$20 goes to the charity of the winner’s choice. 

Resolution criteria

By January 1, 2034, all of the following news outlets will report — as fact, not opinion or editorial — that the AI bubble has popped:

  • The New York Times
  • The Washington Post
  • The Wall Street Journal
  • Bloomberg
  • The Financial Times
  • The Economist
  • The BBC
  • The CBC
  • Le Monde

To repeat, all of these news outlets have to report it. And they have to report it as news. Opinion columns and editorials don’t count.

Explanation

Here's how I landed on the timeframe, stakes, and resolution criteria:

  • The timeframe is ~7 years because I read that many AI investments are amortized over 5 to 7 years.
  • The stakes are low because this bet is mainly just for fun and also to make a point. If you want to bet big money, use the financial markets. Bets are not legally binding, but securities transactions are!
  • The bet defers to news outlets as “judges” because operationalizing the exact conditions under which an AI bubble has or hasn't popped is too complex and too easy to get wrong.[2] Deferring the call to nine highly reputable news outlets in four different countries (the U.S., the UK, Canada, and France) is a good idea because the chance that all the news outlets will get it wrong is minimal.

Again, none of this is set in stone by any means, so please counteroffer me an alternative bet if you've got something better. 

If you'd like to accept this bet or propose something a bit different, feel free to message me here on the EA Forum or on Substack. You can also try my public email address if you prefer, but your email might get stuck in the spam filter. 


Update (2026-10-27 at 9:45am UTC): 

Anthropic's S-1 just came out, so I proposed another bet about Anthropic's revenue growth.

  1. ^

    Wikipedia definition of a bubble:

    An economic bubble (also called a speculative bubble, asset bubble, or simply financial bubble) is a period when current asset prices greatly exceed their intrinsic valuation, being the valuation that the underlying long-term fundamentals justify.

  2. ^

    For instance, what if the valuations of OpenAI and Anthropic get decimated but AI datacentre investment continues to grow because open source LLMs take off? 

    Or what if that happens and AI datacentre investment also plummets because open source LLMs become way more efficient but businesses become much more productive and profitable by using them? 

    What if you choose to bet on Nvidia's market cap, using GPU sales a proxy for AI, and then there's a huge resurgence of cryptocurrency mining?

6

0
2

Reactions

0
2

More posts like this

Comments4
Sorted by Click to highlight new comments since:

I would accept this bet in theory, but there are two reasons why I don't want to:

  1. When I've made bets before, it turned out that the headache of managing the bet and the worry of losing were not justified by the expected gains. The former is especially true when the bet is for only $20.
  2. If the bet resolves YES and I have to pay out, then I expect my investments will have lost a lot of value. Given the basic theory of diversification (this bet is not perfectly correlated with my investments), there's still some level at which the bet makes sense to make, but it's a lot of work to figure out that point, and the expected payoff is probably not enough to justify the work.

In recent years I have become more bearish on bets in general, mainly for reason #1. I used to be very pro-betting but now I believe it's rarely worth the effort.

Since this is just a $20 bet for charity, it's purely symbolic and recreational.

If you want to avoid the money aspect altogether, you could just strongly commit to a prediction that by January 1, 2034, the nine aforementioned news outlets will not all report as fact (not opinion or editorial) that the AI bubble has popped.

I don't think betting makes sense at all if you're doing it for financial reasons. Bets are not legally binding. If you win and the other person decides not to pay up, you have no legal recourse. Similarly, if you lose and decide to pay up, you have no way of knowing if the other person would have paid up if they had lost.[1]

Part of the theory behind betting is that it's cognitively helpful because it encourages you to mentally focus much more intensely and carefully on your predictions. That might be true, but there are other considerations I haven't seen many people bring up:

  • Gambling is fun and addictive, and often induces irrational behaviour (e.g., reckless betting, gambling addiction)
  • The idea of winning and losing, especially in public, makes it way more tempting to dig in to your position and way more unappealing to concede you were wrong, or just to reweigh the question evenhandedly
  • People can challenge each to other to bets as an alternative to discussion, and even throw money around (or threaten to throw it around) to put an end to a discussion

For this bet, my thinking is just: betting is fun and this is a fun, small stunt I can use to make a point.


  1. I couldn't get a firm answer on whether bets are technically illegal. Social betting is legal in the U.S., Canada, and the UK, but if the EA Forum turned into an unlicensed marketplace for bets, that would be illegal. Bets on the EA Forum are currently a lot more like social betting than a marketplace, but if there were a lot more bets, then the EA Forum would be a lot more like a betting marketplace. In any case, it's definitely not legally binding. ↩︎

Another bet that may be of interest:

Anthropic just released its S-1 form, which contains the official financial information it must report to the SEC in order to go public. From the S-1, we now know that Anthropic's revenue grew more than 100x (specifically, 112x) from 2023 to 2025. Revenue was:

  • $41 million in 2023
  • $386 million in 2024
  • $4.59 billion in 2025

A few people in the EA community apparently believe this revenue growth rate will continue for the next several years at least. However, I am confident we won't see Anthropic bring in $514 billion in revenue in 2027, which is what extrapolation would imply.

Indeed, I'm confident that Anthropic won't hit half of what extrapolation would imply, which is $257 billion in 2027.

I'm willing to bet as much and would be delighted to wager $20 on it, to be donated to the charity of the winner's choice.

Hey! I replied to your guess in this comment.

Heads up: There is indeed a financial bubble around AI, but AI is going to play a massive role in the transformation of society in parallel. Both statements can be true.

Further explanation in the comment link above. =)

Curated and popular this week
Relevant opportunities